(Disclaimer – despite the venting present in this entry, I am actually very fond of China and the Chinese people, and do not expect either one to change to suit my preferences. Additionally, to the courageous anonymous commenter who last criticized our lack of cultural sensitivity, you may want to stop reading right about here)
Aman again-
Before coming to China, we had a few orientation sessions at UVa to try and acclimate us a little bit before actually coming here. One of the funnier bits of advice they gave us pertained to culture shock – they gave us this piece of paper which had a diagram which looked like a roller coaster, which supposedly described our emotional trajectory after coming to a foreign country, especially how we would experience and deal with culture shock. As far as I have seen, not many of us have had the predicted “Oh my God I can’t deal with this place it’s not America I just want to go home I miss my mom I miss my dad I miss my dog Chinese people scare me” moment. Culture shock, has, to date, not been a problem. What we have experienced, however, can more accurately be termed “culture rage.”
culture rage (kŭl·chər rāj) – n. A feeling of epic anger directed towards a society and its habits, borne of frustration with inefficiency, stubbornness, or a willful neglect of logical thought on the part of your hosts. Examples follow:
Chopsticks. Why? Jerry Seinfeld says it best: “They're hanging in there with the chopsticks. Because, if you think about it, you know, they've seen the fork... by now. I'm sure they've seen the spoon, they're going, ‘Yeah, yeah, they're OK... We're going to stay with the sticks.’ I mean, I don't know how they've missed it: thousands of years ago, Chinese farmer gets up, has his breakfast with the chopsticks, goes out and works all day in the field with a shovel... Hello?... Shovel! Not going out there ploughing 40 acres with a couple of pool cues.” Thank you, Jerry. I have frequently asked the Chinese about this habit, which is absurdly inefficient and messy, speaking from personal experience. You can’t cut things, you can’t stab things, so they fall out of your chopsticks. The response I get – “Well, we think using a fork and knife is hard.” Of COURSE you do. I did too, the first two or three times I tried it when I was like 5 years old and started serving myself food. It’s an acquired skill. I’ve gotten good with chopsticks after a month of using them, and there really is no comparison. You can’t compare a long, thin stick to a steel tool made specifically for dealing with food. But, hell, the Chinese are sticking by their chopsticks.
Table manners. These are partially really funny and partially really cruel. One of our lessons a few weeks ago was about Chinese table manners, so during our one-on-one class a teacher asked me, “Ok, if I came to America, what would I need to know about how table manners are different?” I thought for a second, then told her – “If you want something, you’re going to have to tell somebody you want it – if you say you don’t want something, people are going to think you don’t want it and therefore not give it to you.” Seems like a simple concept, but in China, you’re always supposed to say you don’t want anything, under the assumption that it will be offered to you multiple times and in the end given to you. I have this hilarious mental image of a Chinese guest walking into an American household really thirsty:
American host: “Would you like anything to drink?”
Chinese guest: “Absolutely not”
American host: “Are you sure?”
Chinese guest: “Absolutely.”
American host: “Ok, if you’re sure…”
Chinese guest: “Definitely don’t want anything to drink.”
American host: “Ok.”
Chinese guest: “…but…but… we weren’t done here! I actually do want something! Sorry, I was lying!”
Also, I told her that often in America it’s polite to at least offer to help clean up or do the dishes when you go over somewhere, and she was shocked. In China, the whole inviting someone over to dinner just has this intricate script which must be followed whereby the host kowtows to every whim of a guest while telling the guest how bad a job they are doing of being a host, while the host continuously “begrudgingly” accepts. It’s very complex – I am quite worried that I’m going to mess it up when we go for our home stay at the end of the program. The last bit that she told me was that at the dinner table, children are expected to just sit there quietly at all times. On the face of it this may not sound that weird, but if you think back to your childhood, even at really formal dinners there was often like a kids’ table or something, and you didn’t have to sit at the dinner table the whole time, and you would get engaged by adults in conversation because they feel guilty. Not so in China. In China, you come, sit, stay, and shut up, until you’re grown up. How humane!
Bureaucracy. Oh, my, GOD. If there’s one thing that the Chinese can’t seem to get their head around, it’s the concept that less is more when it comes to paperwork. Anytime you ask a Chinese worker or cashier to do something, make sure you have the time to actually follow it through. Especially if you’re a foreigner – anytime you ask a stranger something, it is insufficient for them to just answer you, they freak out and get four of their friends to come help them answer a simple question, because the thought of interacting with strange foreign people alone is terrifying. The worst part is, the bureaucracy isn’t some construct of the CCP. There is literally a strong bureaucratic mentality totally ingrained into the heads of the Chinese, that they just can’t seem to break. If you make a plan, you stick to it without changing anything, because you made a plan, and plans are meant to be followed, regardless of the situation. A great example – in Beijing, we were on our tour bus just getting back from a long day of touristy toolishness, and we get stopped at the gate to the campus of the university we’re staying it. All of a sudden, the same guards who let the tour bus in the day before now don’t want to let the bus on campus because it’s too big. So our tour guide and teachers get off the bus and literally argue with the guards for like 10 minutes. The guards do their thing, consult with each other, make phone calls to their superiors to see if they can let the bus through. No go. The thing is, the dorm that we were staying in was literally about 300 feet from where that bus was standing. Walk inside the gate, turn right, walk for about a minute, and wham! You’ve arrived at our dorm. However, the plan was, the bus would drive us up to the door, so we’re sticking to it.
Another example – at one of the cafeterias on campus you basically walk down this big counter of food and point to what you want, and a server serves you. But, of course, different dishes cost different amounts, so you can’t just pay a sum then go get a bunch of food, you have to pay for each dish individually. Ok, fine. But wait, you can’t just pay for each dish individually, you have to pay for each dish using a little ticket that you bought at front counter. But wait, not only that, but your tickets have a value – you can buy, for example, a 4 RMB ticket, or a 6 RMB ticket, or 1 RMB tickets. As a result, when you go to pay for a dish, you get change… IN MORE LITTLE TICKETS. Look, YOU ALREADY HAVE LITTLE PIECES OF PAPER THAT HAVE INTRINSIC MONETARY VALUE. WE CALL IT CASH. WHY AM I GIVING YOU MY PIECES OF PAPER WITH MONETARY VALUE IN EXCHANGE FOR SMALLER PIECES OF PAPER WITH MONETARY VALUE IN ORDER TO BUY FOOD? WHY CAN’T I JUST GIVE YOU CASH?!?! Nope, gotta jump through some hoops first. There are countless other examples of this ridiculousness, which would make this post into a book, while it is already getting too long. So now we have this great phrase that we’ve started using when things are taking too long. For example, at a restaurant we were waiting for our food to come, and someone commented that it was taking a long time. The response: “Look, they’ve got to do the paperwork.” Anytime something is taking a long time, “they’ve got to do the paperwork.”
The sleeper train. Ok, in all honesty, I had a great time on our sleeper train to and from Beijing, except for one little thing. The way the train is set up, you have these little cubicles which hold 6 people each, in two bunks of three beds each. On the way to Beijing, I was on the top bunk, right under the ceiling. At 10:30 at night, they hit the lights and turn off the music so people can go to sleep. On the way to Beijing we didn’t have personal lights, so once the lights were out it was pretty much bed time. Ok it’s kind of annoying that they are trying to control when I go to sleep, but fine, I’ll deal. I go to sleep. The next morning, I get a rude awakening. RIGHT above my head, Chinese music just starts BLARING. On the Chinese train, they don’t do “background music.” They turn that sucker up so that it’s like you’re actively listening to the radio – it’s LOUD. That’s problem #1. Problem #2: I roll over and ask Joe what time it is – the answer, “Eh, it’s seven.” WHAT? YOU BLARE MUSIC IN MY FACE AT SEVEN IN THE MORNING? WHO ARE YOU PEOPLE? JUST LET ME SLEEP FOR GODS SAKE, YOU DON’T HAVE TO CONTROL MY EVERY BREATH! I was extremely grumpy as a result of this experience, and my culture rage nearly exploded 7 blood vessels.
Chinese medicine. Along with the bureaucracy, probably the most frustrating culture rage experience I have had, mostly because of how stubborn the Chinese are about this topic. The Chinese are very adamant about the virtues of their ways of treating patients with a variety of conditions. The most reliable mainstay of Chinese medicine is re shui (hot water). Chinese tap water isn’t good to drink, so it has to be boiled before consumption. Additionally, mineral water is relatively expensive, and often considered an unnecessary luxury in many developing countries, so Chinese people don’t drink it. That’s all fine. However, the Chinese also seem to think that drinking really hot water has remarkable medical properties as well. If you’re getting sick, drink re shui. If you’re eating a meal, drink re shui. When I had a fever a few weeks ago, I kid you not, one of our Chinese teachers told me to drink hot water. Let’s think about this for a second. I’m running a fever, i.e. my body is above its normal temperature. Now, the advice you’re giving me, is to drink water that is even hotter than my body’s already abnormally high temperature. Doesn’t this seem just a little counterintuitive? Wouldn’t I not want to consume a substance that will further increase the temperature of my body? Ok… fine. I’ll bite. Tell my why I should drink hot water when I have a fever. Why, because if you drink hot water, your body will get hotter, then sweat, and then when you sweat, your body will cool down.
…Of COURSE! Why didn’t I see that earlier? Why go directly from having a fever to undertaking activities that will lower my body temperature when I can apply the Chinese bureaucratic mentality and take the scenic route, which involves me heating up my body in order to get it to cool down at a later time? I’m not making this up. Apart from the obvious aforementioned benefits of drinking hot water when I have a fever, it also helps to keep the yin and the yang in balance, as well as balance out the elements of the body, you know, water, fire, wood, metal and earth. Right, I forgot about the abstract spiritual workings of my flu. What was Western medicine thinking when it stopped using the Humors for diagnosis 200 years ago? After all this I made jokes about Chinese doctors bleeding me… until I realized that they actually would bleed me, if I had a stroke. No joke. They still bleed people.
Somehow, these things sound not so ridiculous to Chinese people. One of our teachers got defensive and retorted, “Chinese medicine has been around for 5,000 years, why are you questioning it?” You know what else people were doing 5,000 years ago? Wandering the earth in a cold climate hunting migratory animals with spears (or “large, sharpened chopsticks”) and communicating with grunts. Somehow it’s ok to progress from that point based on technological advancement and scientific progress when it comes to building massive skyscrapers downtown, but the hot water flu medication and the leeches, they stay.
And don't even get me started on the language.
--Aman